For gig economy workers in these states, rights are at risk

Mar 14, 2018, 1:27 PM | Updated: Feb 7, 2023, 11:21 am

Should gig economy workers, such as Uber drivers and Taskrabbits, be entitled to the same rights an...

Should gig economy workers, such as Uber drivers and Taskrabbits, be entitled to the same rights and benefits as regular employees?

(CNN Money) — Should gig economy workers, such as Uber drivers and Taskrabbits, be entitled to the same rights and benefits as regular employees?

Currently they aren’t. And many of the online apps and platforms that offer the goods and services these workers provide would like to keep it that way. That frees these companies from having to offer benefits, pay a host of taxes and abide by certain labor laws.

Leading the charge is New York-based Handy, an online platform that connects users with home service providers ranging from plumbers to house cleaners. The company has put bills in front of eight state legislatures this year that would permanently classify most gig workers as independent contractors. All eight bills have passed at least the house or senate in each state and appear likely to be signed into law soon.

Defining gig workers as independent contractors will give platform companies the certainty that their business model will hold up to legal scrutiny, Handy argues.

Over the years, many platform companies — including Handy — have been sued for allegedly misclassifying workers as independent contractors. The legal outcomes have been mixed, with many cases settling before a verdict was reached, or awaiting a Supreme Court decision on whether the arbitration agreements most workers signed can be enforced.

The state laws would prevent such lawsuits in the future by wiping away many of the criteria that usually establish an employer-employee relationship. But labor advocates worry the laws will erode the benefits and protections to which workers should be entitled.

Related: Top court: Uber should be regulated like a taxi company

Currently, the distinction between a contractor and an employee hinges on the idea of control. Telling a worker when and how to perform a job, providing training or supplies, monitoring their activity and determining the rate of pay are all factors that would support a finding that the worker is an employee.

The laws Handy is trying to get passed by the states would enable employers to do many of those things without having to call the worker an employee. That frees them from having to pay workers’ compensation premiums and unemployment taxes or obeying state anti-discrimination and minimum wage laws. They’ll likely be off the hook for federal labor standards and Medicare and Social Security taxes as well, since federal enforcement is sparse.

“They’ll be able to set wage rates, they’ll be able to discipline workers, they’ll be able to fire workers, they’ll be able to monitor workers,” explains Rebecca Smith, deputy director of the National Employment Law Project, a nonprofit worker advocacy group. “Almost everything that makes you an employer under current law, and that other employers abide by, is thrown out the window.”

In previous years, Uber has won similar laws in many states that apply only to “transportation network companies,” principally itself and Lyft. Handy’s bills would apply to any kind of marketplace contractor, with a few exceptions carved out in certain states.

Derek Christian, the Cincinnati-based co-owner of a maid service and a handyman service, said the bills will lead existing employers to convert to a lower-cost independent contractor model in order to compete.

“It won’t just be Handy, it’ll be all of these virtual companies that are out there now,” Christian said. That can be a raw deal for workers, who might be drawn in by a slightly higher hourly rate but then realize they will have to cover their equipment, transportation, insurance and self-employment taxes, he said.

(On its website, Handy says that it pays cleaners “up to” $22 an hour and allows them to negotiate payments. But further down in the employment contract, it lists the fees it charges if the service provider cancels on short notice or doesn’t show up.)

Related: Court says Uber must give its U.K. drivers more rights

In blue states, gig economy companies have offered to provide benefits to their workers, but there’s a catch. Handy pushed a bill in New York that would have allowed platforms to contribute 2.5% of each transaction to a benefits fund in exchange for a guarantee that the workers would remain independent contractors.

Unions and worker advocacy groups opposed the measure, saying it gave away too many rights and protections for workers. Similar “portable benefits” bills are currently under consideration in Washington and New Jersey, but Handy decided to move on to friendlier territory: The mostly-Republican states of GeorgiaIndianaUtahKentuckyTennesseeFloridaIowa, and Colorado.

“If starting with the harder states failed, we’re taking a shot at something’s that a little faster,” said venture capitalist and political strategist Bradley Tuskwhose firm Tusk Ventures ran Uber’s state legislative campaign and now represents Handy. “What is ultimately a better business decision? To try to change the law in a way that you think works for your platform, or to make sure your platform fits into the existing law?”

The bills have been particularly alarming for the National Domestic Workers Alliance, a national nonprofit advocacy group. Palak Shah, the organization’s director of social innovations, recently went to Tennessee to caution lawmakers that the bill would permanently carve many workers out of rights to which they would be entitled as employees.

“It’s just such a sorry excuse for a business model to make vulnerable workers more vulnerable just so you can tell your investors that one day you might be solvent,” Shah said. “This legislation basically ensures that domestic workers online will never have protection.”

Some of the bills faced resistance from organized labor, but most were offered in states where unions have been weakened in recent years by right-to-work laws and Republican electoral victories, so unions only had enough leverage to ask for small changes.

Related: 5 things every gig worker should know

One thing is clear: The federal government likely won’t stand in the way of Handy’s march through the states.

Under the Obama administration, the Department of Labor pursued dozens of cases against companies that misclassified their employees as independent contractors, and issued extensive guidance outlining the distinction between the two.

Trump’s pick for Labor Secretary, Alex Acosta, withdrew that guidance. And at a recent Chamber of Commerce event marketing the launch of a “new economy working group,” Acosta celebrated platform companies for creating a new class of independent “entrepreneurs,” and said the laws should change with the times.

“Our labor laws and regulations were designed in the era of time cards and pneumatic tools,” Acosta said. “In so many areas we’ve updated them, but we haven’t when it comes to this.”

™ & © 2018 Cable News Network, Inc., a Time Warner Company. All rights reserved.

KSL 5 TV Live


FILE - A pedestrian walks past a First Republic Bank in San Francisco on April 26, 2023. Regulators...

Ken Sweet

First Republic up in air as regulators juggle bank’s fate

Regulators continued their search for a solution to First Republic Bank’s woes over the weekend before stock markets were set to open Monday.

1 month ago

A hiring sign is displayed in a window of a store in Manhattan on December 02, 2022 in New York Cit...

Julia Horowitz

14 million jobs worldwide will vanish in the next 5 years, new economic report finds

Huge disruptions will rock the global job market over the next five years as the economy weakens and companies boost adoption of technologies such as artificial intelligence.

1 month ago

General Mills recalls Four Gold Medal Unbleached and Bleached All Purpose Flour. (U.S. Food & Drug)...

Carma Hassan

General Mills issues voluntary recall for some types of popular flour brand

Select bags of Gold Medal flour are being voluntarily recalled by manufacturer General Mills for the possible presence of salmonella, according to a company.

1 month ago

Jesse Moltenbrey had her wedding dress held 'hostage' in a billing dispute between Bed Bath Beyond ...

Ramishah Maruf

Wedding dress held ‘hostage’ in billing dispute with Bed Bath & Beyond

It's what every bride has nightmares about: A wedding dress disappeared, stained, or — in New Hampshire resident Jesse Moltenbrey's case — held "hostage."

1 month ago


Shelby Lofton

Defective ear tags are threatening the health of Utah cattle herds

A number of veterinarians and ranchers across the state are dealing with an unusual problem, missing ear tags from bulls.

1 month ago

Wendy's chili will soon be sold at grocery stores. (Conagra Brands, Inc. via CNN)...

Jordan Valinsky

Wendy’s will start selling canned chili in grocery stores

Wendy's famous chili is typically sold hot at its restaurants. Soon, Wendy's will sell its chili in canned form at grocery stores.

1 month ago

Sponsored Articles

Stack of old laptops with dark background...

PC Laptops

Old Laptop Upgrades You Need to Try Before Throwing it Away

Get the most out of your investment. Try these old laptop upgrades before throwing it out to keep it running fast and efficient.

Happy diverse college or university students are having fun on their graduation day...

BYU MBA at the Marriott School of Business

How to Choose What MBA Program is Right for You: Take this Quiz Before You Apply!

Wondering what MBA program is right for you? Take this quiz before you apply to see if it will help you meet your goals.

Close up of an offset printing machine during production...

Les Olson IT

Top 7 Reasons to Add a Production Printer to Your Business

Learn about the different digital production printers and how they can help your company save time and money.

vintage photo of lighting showroom featuring chandeliers, lamps, wall lights and mirrors...

Lighting Design

History of Lighting Design | Over 25 Years of Providing Utah With the Latest Trends and Styles

Read about the history of Lighting Design, a family-owned and operated business that paved the way for the lighting industry in Utah.

Fiber Optical cables connected to an optic ports and Network cables connected to ethernet ports...

Brian Huston, CE and Anthony Perkins, BICSI

Why Every Business Needs a Structured Cabling System

A structured cabling system benefits businesses by giving you faster processing speeds and making your network more efficient and reliable.

notebook with password notes highlighted...

PC Laptops

How to Create Strong Passwords You Can Actually Remember

Learn how you can create strong passwords that are actually easy to remember! In a short time you can create new ones in seconds.

For gig economy workers in these states, rights are at risk