COURTS & LEGAL

Utah judge considers delay on law requiring abortions to happen in hospitals

Apr 29, 2023, 9:34 AM | Updated: 2:24 pm

SALT LAKE CITY — A Utah judge is now considering a request from Planned Parenthood to place an injunction on a law that would ban abortions from taking place in clinics, saying a written decision will be issued early next week.

Planned Parenthood of Utah challenged HB467, a law passed by the Utah Legislature this year that is scheduled to go into effect on May 3, which also prohibits clinics from seeking the license they need from the state to perform abortions.

At a 3rd District Court hearing on Friday, before Judge Andrew Stone, Planned Parenthood’s lawyer Hannah Swanson argued the ban on abortions in clinics would effectively end abortions in the state. She argued Planned Parenthood’s abortion clinics are similarly situated to provide abortions as hospitals so the law discriminates against the clinics, treating them differently than medical facilities with hospital licenses.

According to Swanson, abortions at clinics are just as safe as hospitals but are available at a significantly lower cost.

She said although hospitals are allowed to provide abortions, they typically only provide them in specific circumstances — the same ones outlined in a 2020 Utah law, known as the trigger law, that is currently stopped from going into effect by the courts.

This preliminary injunction request is part of the same case Planned Parenthood filed in 2022 against the trigger law banning abortion except under certain circumstances — such as rape, incest or serious risk of death to the mother. Stone previously entered an injunction stopping that law from going into effect, and that injunction is being briefed for consideration by the Utah Supreme Court.

Swanson agreed that this law stopping abortions in clinics would have the same effect. She said that in blocking the trigger ban, Stone recognized the widespread harm that would be caused by not allowing general abortions. She said this law would essentially cause the same harm, as well, since over 95% of abortions in Utah are performed in clinics.

“Requiring abortion to be performed in hospitals does nothing to improve patient safety,” she said. “Abortion is already one of the safest medical treatments available.”

Lance Sorenson, an attorney representing Utah, argued that HB467 does apply the law uniformly. He argued it does not create a classification for abortion clinics but gets rid of one, so that they are treated similarly to other health care facilities if they seek to be licensed as such. He said hospitals operate with higher care standards.

Sorenson said under the 2022 decision in Dobbs v. Jackson, which overturned Roe v. Wade, any abortion regulations are constitutional, and requiring abortions to happen only in hospitals would also be constitutional.

He said the Legislature has the discretion to make laws, whether or not their intent is health and safety, and Utah and the public have an interest in those laws taking effect “especially when there is a question of constitutionality.”

Sorenson said there is nothing in HB467 that would prevent Planned Parenthood from licensing its clinics as hospitals.

The law is set to take effect on May 3, at which time abortion clinics will no longer be able to apply to be licensed. State officials have said clinic licenses will remain until the beginning of 2024, but Swanson said under their reading of the law they will need to stop offering abortions immediately if the law goes into effect. Swanson said under the law it is a second-degree felony to perform abortions outside a hospital, and licenses can be revoked before someone is proven guilty of that crime.

“HB467 is an abortion ban, and so it violates the Utah Constitution,” she told the judge.

Stone thanked both groups of attorneys for their work on briefs and arguments regarding the injunction, saying the work was “top-notch,” but he said it would not be fair to make a decision in the hearing without further consideration.

“Abortion is health care, and we at Planned Parenthood will do every single solitary thing in our power to make sure that people in Utah are safe, and to keep politicians out of personal health care decisions. We will continue fighting, in any court at any time, to ensure that women’s health and family health is protected,” said Sarah Stoesz, interim CEO of Planned Parenthood Association of Utah, in a press conference following the hearing.

Stoesz said no Utah hospitals have stepped forward to say they will help provide abortions if the law goes into effect, and pregnant women may be left without “safe options” and be required to continue their pregnancies. She said if Utah bans abortion access, pregnancy in the state will become more dangerous.

“This is a very cruel law because it prevents women from coming to clinics to seek abortion care, and it prevents Planned Parenthood and clinics from providing safe, accessible, affordable abortion services,” she said.

Stoesz said politicians are “vastly out of step with the voters” on abortion, both around the country and in Utah.

Sorenson said at the press conference that Planned Parenthood is hopeful that Stone will block the ban on abortions in clinics from going into effect before May 3. She said there is no reason their clinics should need to “turn themselves into hospitals” to continue providing the care they have provided safely for many years.

She said an assertion that the law is not an abortion ban “ignores reality.”

KSL 5 TV Live

Courts & Legal

Larry Woodcock speaks to a crowd of media cameras and microphones...

Larry D. Curtis and Lauren Steinbrecher

Victim’s grandfather says evidence ‘unequivocal’ in Lori Vallow Daybell trial

As Lori Vallow Daybell entered the fifth week of her trial facing charges of first-degree murder, a victim's grandfather, Larry Woodcock, said the documentation in the case is "unequivocal."

11 months ago

Tammy Daybell...

Larry D. Curtis and Lauren Steinbrecher

Utah’s ME testifies Tammy Daybell was restrained in hours around her killing

Utah's chief medical examiner testified in Idaho today that Tammy Daybell was restrained around the time of her death and was killed by asphyxiation in late 2019.

11 months ago

New Utah prison...

Pat Reavy

Crime victims sue Utah, saying violent inmates were released but not supervised

A new lawsuit contends the Utah Department of Corrections inappropriately releases violent criminals who were not properly supervised and end up committing murder and other violent crimes.

11 months ago

FILE - Lori Vallow Daybell, appears in court in Lihue, Hawaii, Wednesday, Feb. 26, 2020. The only s...

Larry D. Curtis and Lauren Steinbrecher

Lori Vallow Daybell’s DNA used as evidence for first time in her murder trial

For the first time, Lori Vallow Daybell's DNA has been entered as evidence into her murder trial. A hair found attached to adhesive that is understood — but not clearly stated in court — to be part of the layers of tape found with her son JJ Vallow's body was tested and found to be a match for her.

11 months ago

courtroom sketch...

SAMANTHA HERRERA and Hugo Rikard-Bell, KSL NewsRadio

Idaho murder trial shifts from child victims to Utah mother and wife Tammy Daybell

Testimony in the murder trial of Lori Vallow Daybell Friday, shifted from the death of her children to the death or her current husband's late wife, Tammy Daybell.

11 months ago

A collection of witness portraits from Thursday, April 27, 2023. (Pool)...

SAMANTHA HERRERA, KSL NewsRadio

Forensics show link from Chad Daybell and Alex Cox to burial of Tylee and JJ

The biggest news out of Thursday’s testimony came with the news of victim's blood and DNA was announced as found on tools in Chad Daybell's garage and when an analyst announced that a latent fingerprint from Alex Cox, Lori’s late brother, was found a plastic bag that wrapped JJ’s body.

11 months ago

Sponsored Articles

Stack of old laptops with dark background...

PC Laptops

Old Laptop Upgrades You Need to Try Before Throwing it Away

Get the most out of your investment. Try these old laptop upgrades before throwing it out to keep it running fast and efficient.

Happy diverse college or university students are having fun on their graduation day...

BYU MBA at the Marriott School of Business

How to Choose What MBA Program is Right for You: Take this Quiz Before You Apply!

Wondering what MBA program is right for you? Take this quiz before you apply to see if it will help you meet your goals.

Close up of an offset printing machine during production...

Les Olson IT

Top 7 Reasons to Add a Production Printer to Your Business

Learn about the different digital production printers and how they can help your company save time and money.

vintage photo of lighting showroom featuring chandeliers, lamps, wall lights and mirrors...

Lighting Design

History of Lighting Design | Over 25 Years of Providing Utah With the Latest Trends and Styles

Read about the history of Lighting Design, a family-owned and operated business that paved the way for the lighting industry in Utah.

Fiber Optical cables connected to an optic ports and Network cables connected to ethernet ports...

Brian Huston, CE and Anthony Perkins, BICSI

Why Every Business Needs a Structured Cabling System

A structured cabling system benefits businesses by giving you faster processing speeds and making your network more efficient and reliable.

notebook with password notes highlighted...

PC Laptops

How to Create Strong Passwords You Can Actually Remember

Learn how you can create strong passwords that are actually easy to remember! In a short time you can create new ones in seconds.

Utah judge considers delay on law requiring abortions to happen in hospitals